St. Anthony's Jordan Valcich reacts after winning a shootout in Game 1 of the Suffolk boys ice hockey final against Smithtown on Friday, Feb. 6, 2026, at The Rinx in Hauppauge. Credit: Bob Sorensen
A game that lived up to the hype in every way — and then some.
A 10:10 p.m. puck drop proved worth the wait as St. Anthony’s and Smithtown/Hauppauge exchanged fireworks all night long. Regulation and 10 minutes of overtime weren’t enough in this heavyweight bout.
Tied at 5, a shootout loomed. Thomas Azzariti’s finish put the Friars ahead, and Smithtown/Hauppauge needed a goal to stay alive.
Friars netminder Jordan Valcich made the pad save, and the crowd erupted.
“That was the greatest feeling — I’ve never felt anything like it,” Valcich said. “I knew that last shot determined a lot for the series. It was a mental thing. I got in a groove.”
Follow your favorite local high school sports teams and get scores, highlights and rankings every Monday and Friday.
By clicking Sign up, you agree to our privacy policy.
Valcich stopped all three attempts in the shootout, lifting No. 2 St. Anthony’s to a 6-5 victory over No. 1 Smithtown/Hauppauge in Game 1 of the Suffolk finals at The Rinx on Friday night.
“This team is built from the net out — it starts with him,” St. Anthony’s coach Bob Lund said. “In Jordan we trust.”
Game 2 is scheduled at 9:40 p.m. Monday at The Rinx in Hauppauge.
Two years ago, Smithtown/Hauppauge won a shootout in Game 2 of the finals and went on to capture the championship. Azzariti missed in that game, but this time he delivered.
“He was going no matter what because I trust him,” Lund said. “This was redemption for him.”
“I saw the top of the net open and I wanted to roof one,” Azzariti said. “This is a great feeling. All my boys here and in the stands — it’s everything you want.”
The emotion-packed first period started fast. Anthony Cutalo opened the scoring just 1:21 into the game for the Friars.
From there, both teams traded heavy hits and goals.
Liam McNamara tied it at one with a breakaway finish at 5:44 of the first. Azzariti then scored on an odd-man rush to give St. Anthony’s a 2-1 lead after one.
Just 1:32 into the second period, Brendan Power ripped a shot top-shelf to tie the game at 2.
Cutalo danced past a defender and sniped a shot home, celebrating in front of a standing-room-only crowd to make it 3-2 with 11:42 left in the second.
“I was on a whole other planet, just dialed in,” Cutalo said. “I saw a corner and picked it. That’s the best feeling.”
McNamara answered with a deflection to tie the game at 3. Azzariti then scored again, and the Friars carried a 4-3 lead into the third.
The Bulls responded again. McNamara completed his hat trick by crashing the net, and his linemate Marcus D’Errico followed with a go-ahead goal with eight minutes left.
“Liam is bought in as a 200-foot player and played great,” Smithtown/Hauppauge coach Mark Dubeau said. “Offensively, we battled. Defensively, we made too many mistakes that led to their goals, and we need to clean that up in Game 2.”
With 2:27 remaining, Christian Buttacavoli fired a shot from the point that found the back of the net to tie the game. McNamara rang a shot off the pipe with under a minute left, sending the game to overtime.
Jacob Caradonna and Valcich each made difficult saves in overtime to force a shootout.
This time, Azzariti and Valcich came up clutch.
The Newsday app makes it easier to access content without having to log in.
Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months
Privacy Policy | Terms of service | Subscription terms | Your ad choices | Cookie Settings | California Privacy Rights | About Us | Contact Newsday | Reprints & permissions | Advertise with Newsday | Help
Copyright ©2026 Newsday. All rights reserved.