Hockey fans, let’s have an honest moment: Is the NHL losing its edge? In a recent episode of Belly Up Sports Highlight Shows, Brent Radlinsky took a seat at the Fourteen Twenty Sports Bar and poured out his frustrations with the current state of professional hockey. Let’s dig into his arguments and see if the NHL has, in fact, become a watered-down product.
One of Radlinsky’s central points is the rapid expansion of the NHL. The league has ballooned to 32 teams, which means over 800 roster spots. But are there really 800 high-level players worthy of the world’s top hockey league? According to Radlinsky, no way:
“Are there 800 high level guys? And by high level, I mean game changers. Guys that you can’t live without. No, there’s not.”
He reminisces about the days of 21, 24 teams when the player pool was smaller and the quality of athletes on the ice was much higher. These days, too many third- and fourth-liners are just “filler AHL products,” not guys who would have made the cut even a few decades ago.
The league’s answer? More expansion. Cities like Atlanta, Houston, or even Quebec City are thrown around as possible destinations. But Radlinsky asks: Will anybody outside of those markets even care if teams like the Utah Mammoth, Seattle Kraken, or Columbus Blue Jackets vanish?
His take is clear: fewer teams would make for a better product. Expansion, he argues, simply forces the league to overpay mediocre talent and dilutes the excitement.
Another nostalgic point from Radlinsky: the high-intensity rivalries that once defined the league. The Battle of Alberta used to be “must-see TV”—brutal, emotional, competitive. Now? The rivalry exists more among fans than players.
Brent suggests that because so many players have grown up competing together in youth tournaments, and with free agency mixing up rosters every year, the true dislike between teams has faded. “Now the players don’t dislike each other. They’re so used to playing with each other throughout.”
Here’s the twist—skill is higher than ever. Players are incredible skaters, but the game is “over-coached and over everything.” There’s a lack of character, emotion, and genuine rivalries; everyone feels interchangeable.
NHL regular-season games don’t seem to matter as much. Sure, the Stanley Cup playoffs still bring intensity, but the grind of November matchups like Minnesota vs. Columbus barely moves the needle.
According to Radlinsky, the issue goes all the way to grassroots hockey. Youth programs are expensive and driven by pay-to-play systems, often prioritizing stats and skill development over grit and the will to win. The result? A generation of “same kid with the same haircut named Aiden or Jaden” who’s trained to skate efficiently, not compete fiercely.
Brent doesn’t think the game is dead, but he’s clear: it’s far from healthy. Attendance is lagging in many markets, fans are frustrated by limited streaming access, and the game’s general entertainment value is slipping—at least in his eyes and those of many fans in his age bracket.
That’s the million-dollar question, and Brent figures it’s doubtful:
“Is it fixable? I don’t think it is. Because right now in a rink near you that same kid who’s going to be up there in three years from now, four years from now is learned the exact same way.”
He calls for fewer teams and a return to a smaller, higher-quality league. Fewer expansion drafts, less dilution, more competition.
Listen to the Fourteen Twenty Sports Bar Podcast here on Spotify! https://open.spotify.com/show/59d7IEfk3JR1RLq5nayHsX?si=4651ad0cf2a241d6
Final Thoughts
Hockey’s soul, Brent argues, is in danger. The league’s push for parity has resulted in mediocrity, not the fierce, entertaining product many fell in love with. Maybe it’s generational. Maybe it’s just “old man shouting at clouds.” But if you feel the game has lost its bite, you’re not alone.
Agree? Disagree? Share your thoughts, keep the conversation going in your local sports bar or online. Hockey’s worth it.
Catch the full episode and more at Belly Up Sports. Subscribe, comment, and join the debate.
Want more? Check out BellyUpSports.com for articles, podcasts, and sports banter. And, as always, it’s not where you are, it’s who you’re with!
Hockey News